Key Takeaways
- Net new customer growth at SMB software stalwarts like HubSpot and Monday.com dropped sharply across the last three to four quarters.
- Public cloud vendors masked shrinking buyer acquisition for two years by pushing aggressive price increases on existing accounts.
- Boards at companies like HubSpot and UiPath recalled their original founders after standard operational playbooks failed to fix growth stalls.
- Rory O’Driscoll warns that a returning founder faces severe limits when trying to reverse the trajectory of a company generating one billion dollars in revenue.
- Small businesses are swapping seat-based workflow apps for simpler setups using Google Sheets paired with raw AI prompts.
The Price Hike Cover-Up Falls Apart
For two straight years, enterprise and mid-market SaaS companies reported respectable top-line growth. They beat quarterly revenue guidance, defended their multiples, and told Wall Street that small business demand remained healthy.
Jason Lemkin argues that this narrative was an illusion. Companies were not winning more customers. They were simply charging their existing base more money each year. Now, the math has run out. Net new customer additions at public bellwethers HubSpot and Monday.com have plummeted.
As Lemkin points out, net new logos reveal the actual health of software businesses: “It is the only thing that matters at scale and people hid this for 2 years with endless price increases.” (play from 35:05) When a company stops adding fresh accounts, expansion revenue from older cohorts can only prop up top-line numbers for so long. Once price fatigue sets in, the underlying contraction becomes visible to everyone.
Small businesses are actively refusing new seat licenses. They are not writing custom software from scratch, but they are hacking together workarounds that cost almost nothing. Lemkin puts it bluntly: “SMBs are saying I don't want to buy this crap. I just don't want to buy it. I'm going to whether it's a little bit of data analysis in chat GB without knowing I'm doing doing data analysis. Whether it's running it in Google Sheets for another 6 months because with chat GBT it's good enough.” (play from 45:42)
Why Founder Mode Faces Hard Math at Scale
When standard operating playbooks break down, software boards reach for an emergency lever: bringing back the original builder. Brian Halligan stepped back into HubSpot, mirroring similar founder restorations at enterprise vendors like UiPath.
Boards assume a returning founder will restore product velocity and reignite sales. Rory O’Driscoll is skeptical that sheer founder drive can overcome macro buyer resistance once an enterprise reaches scale. “I think it is really hard to dramatically change the trajectory of a billion dollar revenue company, right?” (play from 38:09) O’Driscoll notes. “You're probably playing for some version of instead of having only 5,000 customers going down to 2,000, I can get it back up to 8,000. I can do better.” (play from 38:16)
A returning founder can clean up product bloat and trim bureaucratic waste. But if the market refuses to buy five seats of an operational tracking tool because a single prompt-driven spreadsheet replaces the workflow, no amount of internal grit reopens customer checkbooks. The seat model itself is what the customer is rejecting.
What to Do With This
Audit your revenue breakdown from the last four quarters this week. Separate expansion revenue generated by price increases from genuine net new account acquisitions. If your net new customer count dropped while average contract value rose, you are running on borrowed time: build an automated, outcome-priced workflow tier before your buyers replace your seats with an off-the-shelf AI agent.