Key Takeaways

  • Steve West warned that a 24-team playoff puts secondary bowls on the endangered species list. That field size would absorb most winning programs and drain interest from minor games.
  • Wes Mitchell noted that South Carolina supporters dreamed of the postseason during a 4-game winning streak. That total convinced fans that their team could make the national bracket.
  • Mitchell argued that 12 teams is the ideal bracket size. That number protects regular season stakes while excluding unproven teams.
  • West proposed turning minor bowl games into a playoff for the G6 leagues. That classification covers mid-major conferences seeking real postseason stakes.
  • West suggested granting 1 automatic bid in the primary bracket to the top mid-major team. That guaranteed spot preserves tournament access for top underdogs.

Secondary Bowls Face an Endangered Future

Steve West warned that traditional bowl games are sliding toward the "endangered species list." That phrase describes how non-playoff matchups lose public interest every December. Portal departures and player opt-outs have stripped these December games of their best talent.

Wes Mitchell noted that fan behavior shifts once a team wins games. South Carolina enjoyed a 4-game winning streak during their season. That stretch shifted fan expectations away from ordinary bowl destinations.

Mitchell said: “I'm not saying people don't care about the bowls anymore. I I hope they still care, because I you know, I love college football traditions as much as anybody. But you know, for for this four-game stretch where South Carolina was winning, you know, back to back to back to back, you hear people start dreaming about, hey, this team can make the playoff.” (play from 9:58)

Mitchell pointed out that an SEC team previously aimed for a 4-4 conference record before playing a cupcake non-conference opponent. That league mark represented an even split against SEC rivals.

A rivalry victory over Clemson would secure an 8-4 regular season. That win count once sent a satisfied fan base to the Outback Bowl.

Today that satisfaction is gone.

A Separate Playoff for the Mid-Majors

West argued that expanding the playoff will push secondary bowls further toward that endangered species list. He warned that administrators might eventually create a 24-team tournament. That field size would absorb almost every winning roster across the power conferences.

West said: “Yeah, we go to 24-team playoff. You're going to see a lot of these secondary bowls be on the endangered species list.” (play from 13:48) Opt-outs and portal entries already leave games like the Music City Bowl and the Las Vegas Bowl with skeleton rosters.

Mitchell believes 12 teams is the right limit for the postseason. That field size protects the value of regular season games while keeping out unproven rosters.

Mitchell said: “I think 12 gives you a pretty good mix of the regular season still very much matters, but you know, it's not a thing where you just have teams that have no business making a playoff making a playoff.” (play from 11:06)

To rescue secondary bowls, West proposed transforming lower-tier games into a dedicated playoff for the G6 group. That division covers mid-major leagues outside the power conferences.

West said: “I'm just wondering if there's a way for there to be a G6 playoff. You still keep that best G6 team and put them in the 24-team field, two if they're good enough, but maybe the rest of them have the playoff, because people are stuck at home, and they watch these games.” (play from 14:09)

Under that plan, West would preserve 1 automatic bid into the primary bracket for the top mid-major squad. That guaranteed slot keeps the door open for top underdogs.

West noted that administrators could admit 2 mid-major teams if their resumes warranted inclusion. That second bid rewards a dominant season.

Meaningful trophies beat empty exhibition games.

What It Means for Georgia

This debate leaves Georgia fans feeling secure that our program operates far above the anxieties of the holiday bowl circuit. Georgia remains built for late-season playoff football rather than fighting for survival on the endangered species list.

The looming matchup against South Carolina will reveal whether our roster can extinguish an SEC rival's postseason hopes before tournament expansion ever takes place.