Why AI Shopping Agents Pick Expensive Products
Lindsay Owens reveals why shopping bots scan your inbox to charge you more, skewing results toward higher-margin products.
AI Agents Are Already Changing the Price of Goods
Joe Weisenthal and Tracy Alloway speak with Lindsay Owens, president of Groundwork Collaborative and author of 'Gouged,' about how AI agents and algorithmic pricing are reshaping consumer markets. Owens discusses research showing AI shopping agents recommending more expensive goods, investigates surveillance pricing tactics like battery-level tracking, and explains why modern dynamic pricing erodes the historical benefits of the fixed public price tag. The conversation also explores the need for fiduciary standards for AI shopping assistants and examines algorithmic price-fixing cases across retail, housing, and food.
Key takeaways
- In a study testing 325,000 shopping agents, bots instructed to find the cheapest product systematically recommended more expensive goods. Read more →
- RealPage enabled competing landlords to share sensitive market data and coordinate prices, driving apartment rents up to 25% above competitive market levels. Read more →
- Research shows commercial AI shopping agents frequently direct buyers toward more expensive items instead of uncovering the best available price. Read more →
- The fixed price tag is only about 150 years old, popularized in the late 1870s by Philadelphia department store founder John Wanamaker. Read more →
- Groundwork Collaborative, Consumer Reports, and More Perfect Union recruited 400 secret shoppers across four US markets to audit Instacart orders simultaneously. Read more →
- Personalized pricing is rebranded first-degree price discrimination, using real-time surveillance to strip away consumer surplus. Read more →
6 articles from this episode
Algorithmic Price-Fixing Is Quietly Killing Competition
Lindsay Owens explains how software like RealPage, Kalibrate, and McDonald's algorithms coordinate prices and wipe out price competition.
Why AI Shopping Agents Need a Fiduciary Duty
Lindsay Owens explains why AI shopping assistants steer buyers to higher prices and why agentic commerce needs a legal best-interest standard.
Why Quaker Price Tags Beat Algorithmic Pricing
Lindsay Owens explains how fixed pricing protected consumers for 150 years and why modern dynamic pricing threatens that balance.
Instacart: Secret Shoppers Found 75% of Groceries Varied in Price
A 400-person investigation into Instacart found identical grocery baskets varied by up to 23%, adding up to $1,200 in annual costs for some families.
Lindsay Owens on Algorithmic Pricing and Device Telemetry
Lindsay Owens and Joe Weisenthal debate whether dynamic surge pricing helps stranded consumers or exploits their desperation.
More Odd Lots episodes
- The Forgotten Godmother of Economic LiteratureOct 25 · 5 articles
- How a Chicago Restaurant Has Stayed Open For Nearly Three DecadesOct 25 · 3 articles
- CME's Terry Duffy on the Disconcerting State of Finance RegulationOct 25 · 5 articles
- James Robinson on What It Looks Like When a State is FailingOct 25 · 5 articles