Key Takeaways
- American Bar Association regulations ban non-lawyers from owning law firms, which prevents legal practices from raising equity capital or reinvesting annual profits into software.
- United Kingdom legal reforms passed a decade ago permit outside corporate ownership of law firms, creating a regulatory opening for Carta to acquire London-based Avantia.
- Carta rejected the gig-economy marketplace approach because contractor networks cannot guarantee service quality or enforce standard operational workflows.
- Direct employment allows Carta to seat software engineers alongside practicing lawyers, creating a direct feedback loop to test and deploy artificial intelligence agents for routine tasks like NDAs.
The Partner Model Starves Legal Tech
American law firms run on a capital structure that guarantees technical stagnation. Under state bar rules across the United States, law firms must be entirely owned by licensed attorneys. That rule blocks outside equity investment. It also bars professional corporate executives from running the business.
As Carta chief executive officer Henry Ward pointed out, the partnership structure creates an incentive problem that kills capital expenditure. Law firms pay out their profits to equity partners at the end of every calendar year. Retaining earnings to spend millions of dollars on software development makes zero financial sense to a senior partner planning to retire in three years.
“They're really rent seeking organizations because all the money flows to the partners at the end of the year,” (play from 50:13) Ward said. “That's why law firms don't use technology, they don't have investment, they don't have management teams. It's because they don't want to invest in the future, because that's not for them. That will be for the future partners of the firm.” (play from 50:39)
Without retained earnings or outside equity, law firms bill by the hour instead of writing code to compress their hours.
Using British Corporate Law to Rebuild Private Capital Work
To bypass that structural roadblock, Carta looked across the Atlantic. The United Kingdom liberalized its legal sector under the Legal Services Act, allowing non-lawyers and corporate entities to own law firms through Alternative Business Structures.
“In Europe, particularly in the UK, they changed that rule about almost 10 years ago, where shareholders can own a law firm,” (play from 51:14) Ward said. “You don't have to be a lawyer to do it. One of the reasons we love the company was they pioneered this structure that allowed us to do it.” (play from 51:24)
Buying Avantia gave Carta a fully regulated legal practice inside its corporate perimeter. Instead of selling workflow software to third-party law firms that have no incentive to buy it, Carta owns the firm itself. The company can capitalize the operation, install professional management, and treat legal work as an operational cost center to automate rather than a billable-hour profit engine.
Why Marketplaces Fail at Professional Work
Most venture-backed attempts to modernize legal services launched freelance marketplaces. They built portals that connect clients with contract attorneys on an hourly or fixed-fee basis. Ward argued that the freelance model breaks down as soon as deals demand high consistency.
“Our thesis, and I think it's playing out, is that for a type of service like legal services, you want to be vertically integrated,” (play from 55:07) Ward said. “You actually want to employ the lawyers. You don't want the employers to be contractors, because if there are contractors, it's very hard to control the quality of the service.” (play from 55:17)
Full-time employment also solves the software adoption problem. Independent contractors pick their own tools and resist unfamiliar interfaces. Salaried employees follow company workflows.
“Whereas us, we can be like, 'Hey employees, we have an agent now, now start using this,'” (play from 55:52) Ward said. “And then we can have engineers sit right next to them and create the feedback loop. And so that was one of the thesis of why we chose Avantia Law versus one of these marketplace companies.” (play from 55:57)
Why It Matters
Software companies are moving from selling SaaS subscriptions to service providers toward acquiring the service providers themselves. When regulatory walls or billable-hour incentives prevent incumbent firms from adopting software, vertically integrated operators will use friendly overseas jurisdictions to roll up professional labor and automate it from within.