Key Takeaways

  • Asking someone "what do you do?" acts as code for asking what they are worth financially, which instantly triggers defensive positioning.
  • Skipping baseline small talk entirely fails because humans need demographic safety checks before they open up about real motivations.
  • Business deals close at Level 2, where discussions shift from basic facts to active goals, quarters, and current personal learning.
  • Level 3 reveals an operator's internal myth, exposing whether they view themselves as an underdog, a survivor, or an ambitious hero.
  • Dan McAdams' Three Levels of Connection provides a structured progression for moving conversations from surface facts to real trust.

Dan McAdams' Three Levels of Connection

Vanessa Van Edwards argues that high-stakes relationships fail when founders try to skip steps. As Van Edwards explained, “Dr. Dan McAdams found that there are three levels of connection between all humans. That when we are connecting we have to pass through three levels to feel quote unquote connected to someone.” (play from 42:06) Bypassing the sequence makes people feel cornered, while lingering too long in the first stage kills momentum.

  • Level 1: General Traits: Establish basic demographic facts and baseline information. Instead of standard questions like "What do you do?", use script-breaking alternatives like "Working on anything exciting these days?" or questions about hobbies to establish context without boxing people in.
  • Level 2: Personal Concerns: Uncover motivations, values, personality traits, and goals. Transition into this level by time-boxing questions around quarters, New Year's resolutions, or birthdays, asking: “What's the big goal with that project?” (play from 44:46) or identifying what keeps them up at night and what they are learning.
  • Level 3: Self-Narrative: Identify the overarching story a person tells themselves about who they are (e.g., an "ambitious hero" who overcomes adversity through grit and resilience). This reveals core character and operational defaults.

Van Edwards notes that Level 1 is where conversational defaults live: “This is why as humans we default to what do you do? Where are you from? Got any kids? Are you married? Facts.” (play from 42:18) The trap is staying there. To break out without alienating the other person, substitute the standard opening: “Instead of asking what do you do, and I don't like that question. I think it's basically asking someone what are you worth? I would rather you ask working on anything exciting these days.” (play from 42:40)

Once basic context exists, the conversation must advance. “Once you get the basics done, level two is my favorite level. It's where I think most of the business gets done,” (play from 43:38) Van Edwards said. The third stage takes the longest to surface: “Level three is your self-narrative. That's the story you tell yourself about yourself.” (play from 45:40)

When This Works (and When It Doesn't)

This framework works when escalating professional networking or social interactions into genuine trust. Most ambitious founders hate small talk. They read an article about vulnerability, attend an investor dinner, and immediately ask a stranger, "What is your biggest fear in life?" The other person freezes. That reaction happens because Level 1 establishes mutual social safety. Skipping it feels like an interrogation.

It breaks down when you force Level 3 into short transactional meetings. If you are negotiating a vendor contract over a twenty-minute call, probing for someone's self-narrative makes you look socially tone-deaf. Keep transactional interactions squarely in Level 2, focused on quarterly goals and operational pressures. Save Level 3 for co-founders, key hires, and long-term partners.

What to Do With This

Pick one networking call or investor catch-up scheduled for this week and write down two replacement questions before dialing in.

Open by establishing factual safety, but replace "How's work?" with “Are you working on anything exciting these days?” (play from 42:47) Once they share a project, pivot straight to Level 2 by time-boxing the outcome: "What is the primary milestone you need to hit on that before the quarter ends?" Listen closely to how they describe obstacles. If they frame every delay as a challenge they were born to conquer, you have just identified their Level 3 hero narrative without ever asking a cheesy personal question.