Key Takeaways
- Standard behavioral questions yield rehearsed case studies; asking for the candidate's most recent hurdle forces them to recall unscripted, real-time problem-solving.
- People who believe they are unlucky view life as something that happens to them, signaling an external locus of control that hinders resilience.
- Candidates project their psychological baseline when asked which fictional character matches their personality, choices, and values.
- As the My First Million hosts noted, candidates who consider themselves lucky tend to get their way often or carry an optimistic bias toward solving problems.
- Founders can evaluate whether an applicant sees themselves as a victim or a protagonist by using Vanessa Van Edwards' Behavioral Hiring Screening Protocol.
The Vanessa Van Edwards' Behavioral Hiring Screening Protocol
Van Edwards screens for self-narrative above raw credentials. As Van Edwards explained, “I want to know your self-narrative at work. I want to know your work narrative. I like hiring ambitious heroes.” (play from 45:46)
Question 1: The Recent Hurdle Query
Ask: “When was the last hurdle you had to overcome, like the most recent one?” (play from 46:30) This bypasses prepared, rehearsed stories and reveals recent problem-solving behavior in real time.
Question 2: Contextual Theoretical Scenarios
Present an unscripted, role-specific operational curveball (for example: “I'm on a flight and you find out the event got pushed three hours; what do you do?” (play from 46:58)) to evaluate cognitive workflow.
Question 3: The Luck Perception Test
Ask: “Do you feel lucky? Are you lucky?” (play from 47:09) Candidates who answer "no" reveal an external locus of control and diminished ability to spot emergent opportunities.
Question 4: The Character Projection Inquiry
Ask: “What book, movie, or TV character is most like you: not in terms of looks, but in terms of personality, life choices, and core values?” (play from 48:28) Do not argue with their answer; use it as an unvarnished window into their internal self-narrative.
When This Works (and When It Doesn't)
This protocol works during final interview rounds to identify resilient, high-agency candidates and screen out individuals with victim mentalities or external loci of control. Van Edwards warns against candidates who view themselves as victims: “Unlucky people typically feel like the world is happening to them. They don't feel like the authors of their own story and that makes it very hard to overcome anything.” (play from 47:40)
Where this breaks down is cross-cultural hiring and neurodivergent evaluations. In cultures that prize humility, claiming to be lucky or comparing oneself to a heroic protagonist can feel arrogant or inappropriate. Similarly, asking for immediate recall of a recent obstacle can disadvantage candidates who need processing time rather than quick improvisation. Use this protocol to understand how someone thinks, not as a rigid filter that punishes reflective thinkers.
What to Do With This
Take your upcoming interview slate this week and strike standard questions like “What is your greatest weakness?” (play from 54:28) from your script. Replace them with the four protocol queries.
When testing an executive assistant candidate, give them the real scenario Van Edwards posed: tell them you are stuck on a flight with no Wi-Fi while an event is delayed three hours, then ask for their immediate sequence of moves. When you ask them if they are lucky, listen to where they place credit and blame. If their recent hurdle story blames colleagues, clients, or bad luck without personal ownership, you have found someone who believes life happens to them. Pass on them and look for candidates who treat hurdles as problems they have the power to solve.