Key Takeaways
- Todd Abbrecht, Co-CEO of THL Partners, traces his 35-year career from the late 1980s LBO era to managing a $6 billion middle-market fund today.
- In the late 1980s and early 1990s, target boards did not consider buyout shops class A buyers, forcing sponsors to win purely through debt execution and financial modeling.
- Financial modeling and deal mechanics commoditized across the 1990s, a trend now accelerated as artificial intelligence automates baseline LBO math.
- With deal execution fully commoditized, private equity returns now rest entirely on post-close operational execution and deploying specialized human capital.
The Era When Deal Structuring Was the Edge
In the late 1980s and early 1990s, buyout firms occupied an insecure position in corporate M&A. Sellers favored strategic acquirers, viewing financial sponsors with suspicion. “So if I go back to the early '90s, there was no private equity industry,” (play from 1:37) Abbrecht explains. “There were LBO shops. And we were not considered a class A buyer of assets.” (play from 1:41)
Because target boards treated financial buyers as second-tier counterparties, sponsor survival required technical mastery that target executives lacked. A firm won transactions by assembling complex debt syndicates and building detailed cash flow models. “A lot of the specialness of the industry in the early '90s in the late '80s was really about how do you get a deal done,” (play from 2:31) Abbrecht notes. “It was about technical know-how. It was how do you create a financial model and then execute these pieces of the puzzle.” (play from 2:39) In that environment, financial engineering generated outsized returns because few market participants possessed the quantitative tools to structure multi-tiered debt packages.
When Software Makes Deal Execution Free
That structural advantage evaporated over the subsequent three decades. Commercial banks standardized leveraged loan underwriting, investment banking analyst classes turned model templates into table stakes, and specialized software automated debt waterfalls. Today, generative tools are removing whatever technical friction remained. As Abbrecht puts it, “That began to commoditize as we went through the '90s and at this point, particularly with the advent of AI, the know-how around how to do an LBO is no longer particularly valuable.” (play from 3:00)
The economic consequence for sponsors running large balance sheets is stark. When anyone can download an LBO model or prompt an AI system to calculate internal rates of return under five debt tranches, the deal process carries zero proprietary margin. Abbrecht draws a clear boundary between mechanics and returns: “So now the transacting is easy, the investing is hard, and we've become investors. And as part of investors, we have to find ways to add value to the assets that we are backing.” (play from 3:30) Host David Weisburd summarized the shift: “So before it was really about putting together the deal, now it's once you invest, how do you add value to the deal?” (play from 3:51)
For a firm overseeing a $6 billion fund, this dynamic reallocates firm expenses. The traditional private equity pyramid, heavy on junior financial analysts building spreadsheet scenarios, loses its economic justification. Capital preservation and multiple expansion now require dedicated operating teams, pricing strategists, and functional executives who can alter EBITDA post-closing.
Why It Matters
Commoditizing the technical transaction layer removes the primary historical defense for high private equity management fees. When debt structuring and baseline underwriting become free automated utilities, LP capital concentrates in firms with genuine operating benches, while pure financial intermediaries face shrinking deal flow and compressed net returns.