Key Takeaways

  • Public equity outperformance over recent quarters rests on seven mega-cap tech stocks, creating concentrated correlation risk rather than broad market strength.
  • Private equity's current backlog of 37,000 unsold portfolio companies matches historical expansion curves seen when the asset class grew from $1 trillion to $10 trillion.
  • Unlisted assets dominate operating scale in the United States, where 80% of businesses generating over $100 million in annual revenue remain privately owned.
  • Higher interest rates have stretched hold periods rather than broken value creation models, pushing managers toward secondary transactions and liquidity structures.

Seven Stocks Distort the Public Baseline

Institutional allocators comparing private buyout returns against public equity benchmarks over the past two years often measure against a distorted yardstick. Public index gains have narrowed to a small cluster of mega-cap technology winners, masking broader economic stagnation across unlisted and listed balance sheets alike.

John Toomey points directly to this concentration when evaluating relative performance. “Now, you know, if you're comfortable carrying the risk of seven companies- all of which are correlated by the way, driving almost all of your returns, keep holding that risk,” (play from 8:20) Toomey says. “If you want actual diversification, then you should consider another equity investment that actually is the broad cross-section of the most economies.” (play from 8:30)

The public equity story looks like index health from high altitude. Underneath, seven names carry the headline returns. Investors who swap private exposure for public index funds are not buying broad enterprise growth; they are buying concentrated tech exposure. By contrast, the broader American corporate economy lives off public exchanges entirely. As Toomey observes, “In the US, 80% of the companies with 100 million more of revenue are private. Like, there are way more investable opportunities.” (play from 8:43) Allocators pulling back from private sponsors to track the S&P 500 miss the actual bulk of mid-market corporate cash flows.

The 37,000 Company Inventory Is Normal Math

Skeptics cite the 37,000 private equity-backed companies currently sitting in global portfolios as proof of structural gridlock. When cheap debt disappeared, exits slowed, leaving funds holding assets past their planned five-year timelines. Critics claim this backlog will choke off distributions and permanently depress internal rates of return.

Toomey views the raw headcount differently. The absolute volume of portfolio assets has expanded steadily across every economic cycle over four decades. “Like, what... Is that, is that a lot?” (play from 10:22) Toomey asks. “If you were to look at that number over the last 40 years, it's probably gone up every year in 40 years. So you could have written that same article 10 years ago to say, like, 'Can you believe it? There's 20,000 private companies that are still stuck in funds,' and yet here we are.” (play from 10:25)

The industry absorbed similar exit anxieties at $1 trillion in total assets under management, then again at $3 trillion, $5 trillion, and $10 trillion. Longer hold durations reflect a reset in borrowing costs, not terminal balance sheet decay. Sponsoring firms adapt by holding quality assets through credit lines, continuation vehicles, and secondary liquidity solutions until pricing multiples stabilize. As Hugh MacArthur points out, the asset class consistently relies on operational flexibility to clear backlog logjams: “Somehow the industry has enough innovation, enough entrepreneurialism and enough resilience that it figures out a way to get through its problems.” (play from 11:05)

Why It Matters

This dynamic signals that institutional capital allocations will remain sticky in private markets despite headline public index rallies. General partners will not dump performing mid-market assets into discounted initial public offerings; they will build larger secondary and evergreen mechanisms to manage inventory. As liquidity pressure shifts from forced asset liquidations to structured hold vehicles, managers who control broad private cash flows hold a durable advantage over stock pickers riding narrow market breadth.