Key Takeaways
- HarbourVest CEO John Toomey argues public and private markets are mispricing software by creating a blunt binary: assets labeled AI winners trade up, while incumbent vertical software gets treated as terminal risk.
- Point solutions without proprietary data or deep workflow integration face immediate margin compression, but deeply embedded vertical software providers are using cheaper code generation to widen margins and raise prices.
- Toomey observes a growing operational split among private equity sponsors, separating firms actively converting technology into portfolio efficiencies from those presenting slideware based on generic subscriptions to ChatGPT, Claude, and Copilot.
- The primary source of sponsor alpha in the current cycle is execution speed: because efficiency gains compound, firms that operationalize tooling across their portfolio companies will outpace peers who only run high-level pilots.
The False Binary in Software Pricing
Markets love a simple story, and right now that story assumes generative software tools will wipe out traditional software providers. Toomey views that panic as an opportunity born from lazy underwriting. As Toomey told Hugh MacArthur on Dry Powder, “Today, the market is pricing if it's related to AI, it's gonna be great, and if it's AI's on the other side of that, it's gonna be terrible. And to me, that's where the opportunity is because they're not all going to work out, and they're all not going to be written down to zero.” (play from 13:02)
The panic treats every B2B software vendor like a replaceable text generator. The reality on the ground looks different. Software businesses divide into two camps. In the first camp are thin applications that simply wrap around basic business tasks. These vendors have no structural defense. As Toomey noted, “There are definitely software companies who don't have a competitive moat in some way... They don't have proprietary data. They are deeply embedded in the workflow of a particular industry or a particular type of business or part of the value chain, and there absolutely are companies that are exposed, that are, that are going to, going to suffer.” (play from 12:21)
In the second camp sit platforms woven directly into daily operations, holding decades of customer records and complex regulatory logic. These companies do not lose their customers because writing code got cheaper. Instead, lower engineering costs widen their operating margins. They can ship new features in weeks rather than quarters, bundle automated tools directly into existing seats, and capture more value. As Toomey observed across active buyout sponsors, “for many of them, they see actually tailwinds, right? An opportunity to actually increase pricing, to add services and enhancements.” (play from 12:03)
Moving Past the Slideware Divide
Evaluating sponsor claims about technical readiness requires looking past standard annual meeting presentations. Nearly every private equity manager now claims to have an aggressive plan for technological adoption. In practice, Toomey sees a wide gap between true operational adoption and marketing theater.
“To me, like, all this technology is available to all of us, as long as you're, uh, willing to pay for it,” (play from 13:41) Toomey said. “To me, the killer app for the manager is how quickly they can absorb, convert, and deploy it because these benefits compound.” (play from 13:48)
The divide reveals itself in the portfolio reviews HarbourVest conducts as an institutional allocator. Progressive sponsors integrate custom automated pipelines into portfolio sales funnels, customer onboarding, and back-office shared services. Laggards, meanwhile, show up with lists of commercial licenses. Toomey pointed out that “some managers are very progressive in what they're actually doing, and some are still at the slideware range around the like we have Chat, we have Claude, and, and, and we have Copilot.” (play from 14:01) Off-the-shelf access to frontier models does not create a competitive edge when every rival firm holds the exact same enterprise license.
Why It Matters
This split signals a pricing dislocation that secondary buyers and value-oriented buyout shops can exploit. Software assets written off as disruption casualties by generalist investors will trade at compressed entry multiples despite durable recurring revenue, while sponsors who build repeatable operational deployment engines will deliver compound margin gains that purely financial engineering can no longer match.