Key Takeaways

  • Good Culture passed $200 million in annual revenue while fulfilling less than 50% of actual customer demand.
  • Cottage cheese processing capacity across the United States was tapped out, turning manufacturing equipment into the company's growth ceiling.
  • A viral TikTok recipe caused an unexpected spike in consumer interest that domestic dairy co-packers could not handle.
  • Merrill chose to sell a majority stake to private equity firm L Catterton instead of taking on debt or raising small equity rounds.
  • The recapitalization let Merrill stay on as CEO with an explicit target of building a $1 billion brand.

Demand Is Fake If Your Factories Cannot Ship

Most founders believe their main job is manufacturing customer demand. Jesse Merrill discovered the opposite problem: demand can outrun your physical supply chain until your topline numbers reflect machine uptime rather than market appetite.

Good Culture cleared $200 million in revenue, but the business was choking on its own growth. A viral TikTok cottage cheese recipe ignited consumer runs on grocery dairy aisles. Merrill discovered that the processing plants capable of making high-protein, clean-label cottage cheese did not exist at scale.

As Merrill put it: “There was a finite amount of cottage cheese capacity in the space because there wasn't a lot happening in cottage cheese before that happened, and suddenly everyone's scrambling to get more capacity because we need to support this, exponential growth that is occurring.” (play from 1:06:28)

When a physical product goes viral, you cannot spin up AWS servers. You need pasteurizers, vats, specialized packaging equipment, cold storage, and certified plants. Because those assets did not exist, Merrill was stuck rationing product.

“We're currently servicing less than 50% of demand,” (play from 1:12:00) Merrill said. “We did north of $200 million in revenue last year, we'll do much more than that this year, and again that does not come close to reflecting demand. That reflects capacity.” (play from 1:12:04)

When Private Equity Beats Venture Capital

When consumer brands face a manufacturing wall, founders usually turn to mezzanine debt or another small equity round. Merrill realized that incremental capital would not solve an industrial problem. Buying dedicated plants, retooling machinery, and hiring supply chain veterans required deep operational backing.

Merrill sold a majority stake in Good Culture to private equity firm L Catterton. For venture-backed founders trained to guard their equity percentage above all else, handing over control sounds like surrender. Merrill viewed it as the only way to avoid strangling the business.

“We really wanted to bring on a partner that brought sophistication, experience, rigor, folks that have scaled businesses from our size to something bigger, that have gone through similar challenges, that had a proven track record,” (play from 1:13:59) Merrill explained.

He wanted operators who understood cold chain logistics and plant construction, not financial investors looking for a quick markup on a spreadsheet. Selling control gave him access to institutional scale while keeping him in the driver seat as CEO.

“I'm still maniacally focused on unit economics, good fundamentals, EBITDA, ensuring we have a healthy, enduring business,” (play from 1:15:03) Merrill said. “I believe there's a ton of head space, a ton of opportunity ahead, and I want to turn Good Culture into a billion-plus dollar business, into a household name.” (play from 1:15:48)

If you own 80% of a business that caps out at $200 million because you cannot build factories, you built a smaller asset than owning a minority piece of a $1 billion brand.

What to Do With This

Run an unconstrained demand audit this week. Look at your order volume, stockouts, backorders, and inbound retail inquiries. Calculate the exact dollar amount of business you turned away or delayed over the last two quarters. If that number exceeds 30% of your current revenue, stop spending cash on top-of-funnel marketing today and put every dollar into operational throughput.