Key Takeaways
- Good Culture grew to $70 million in revenue by selling cottage cheese through traditional grocery channels before social media changed the trajectory of the business.
- In 2023, influencer Lainey Kress posted a recipe blending Good Culture into high-protein cheesecake ice cream, sparking a viral cascade across flatbreads, pasta, and eggs.
- Older generations required constant brand education to overcome memories of cottage cheese as a bland diet food, whereas Gen Z adopted the product with zero historical prejudice.
- The viral wave cleared grocery shelves across the United States, helping propel Good Culture past $200 million and lifting the overall cottage cheese category to $2.4 billion.
Unlearning Old Brand Prejudices Takes Too Long
For nearly a decade, Jesse Merrill faced an uphill battle. He started Good Culture after dietary restrictions from ulcerative colitis led him to clean-label dairy. He knew the product tasted better than incumbent brands, but older shoppers carried decades of baggage. Millennials and Gen X remembered cottage cheese as a watery, lumpy diet food from the 1970s and 1980s.
Good Culture had to spend real capital teaching these older cohorts that cultured dairy could taste rich and clean. Merrill grew the company to $70 million through retail distribution and targeted influencer seeding, but every sale required persuasion. Merrill put it plainly: “With millennials and younger Gen X, you had to like help help them understand why cottage cheese can be cool, why it can be better, why all these things. With Gen Z, it was inherently a cool food that they that they discovered on TikTok through an aspirational influencer. That was it.” (play from 1:05:18)
Generations without product memories do not need brand rehabilitation. They only need a reason to care.
The Recipe Hack Snowball
When influencer Lainey Kress blended Good Culture into high-protein ice cream on TikTok, she did not review the tub or talk about clean farming. She showed a culinary shortcut. That distinction mattered. Viewers did not see a diet snack; they saw a macro-friendly base ingredient for dessert.
Once that door opened, the internet ran with it. “And it goes from ice cream to flatbreads to bagels to smoothies to eggs to, you know, various pasta dishes, etc. It just it just keeps snowballing,” (play from 1:06:00) Merrill recalled. “And influencers are creating more recipes, and Gen Zers are creating more recipes, millennials are creating more recipes, and it just keeps going.” (play from 1:06:13)
Each recipe solved a different meal occasion. A single tub was no longer competing with yogurt for breakfast. It was replacing heavy cream in pasta sauce and flour in sandwich wraps. The sudden pull emptied retail shelves across the country. Merrill joked about the personal shift: “I tell the story that I went from being the lame cottage cheese dad to being the cool cottage cheese dad overnight.” (play from 1:07:34) The broader category expanded to $2.4 billion, and Good Culture scaled past $200 million.
What to Do With This
Audit your product positioning tomorrow morning. If you sell an ingredient or a tool, stop telling potential users why your core product is superior. Seed 10 creators with a brief to use your product as a cheat code inside a popular, unrelated project. Let them show an end result that people already desire.